ccf-idea-reviewer
Assess research ideas before experiments begin.
What it does
Evaluates research ideas and returns a concept-level verdict grounded in their importance, novelty, insight, and logical coherence.
When to use it
Use to judge a research concept, assess novelty, decide whether it merits further work, or compare ideas.
How to use it
Give it a research idea; it returns a detailed conceptual review, with a brief version only when explicitly requested.
Good to know
- cannot be undone: ../ccf-common/references/source-registry.yaml
- edits its own instructions
What you need · 4
Must be applied before specialist execution, including work without prose.
Must be applied after ccf-humanization and before specialist execution; applicable rules carry across handoffs.
Access · 3
This skill
../ccf-common/references/source-registry.yaml
Updates the shared source registry (irreversible)
public research papers
Reads related research papers